5.3 Review and improve
A journal is only useful if you read it. Set aside fixed time for review – for example half an hour every Sunday and an hour at the end of each month.
The key numbers
| Number | What it tells you |
|---|---|
| Number of trades | Are you trading too much or too little? |
| Win rate | How often you win |
| Average win and loss in R | How big the wins are compared with the losses |
| Expectancy in R | Do you have an edge? |
| Largest drawdown | How painful it was along the way |
| Profit factor | Sum of wins ÷ sum of losses. Above 1.5 is good |
| Share of trades following the plan | Are you disciplined? |
The questions
- Which setups made money? Which lost?
- Are there times of day or days of the week when I trade worse?
- Which trades broke the plan – and what did they cost?
- Did I cut winners too early? Hold losers too long?
- What is one thing I will do better next week?
One improvement at a time
It is tempting to change everything after a bad week. But if you change five things at once, you will not know what worked. Choose one improvement, test it over at least 20–30 trades, and judge the result.
A finding in the journal
A trader sees in her journal that all trades she took after 21:00 added up to −6R, while her daytime trades gave +11R. She introduces one new rule: no new trades after 20:00. The next month is better – without changing the strategy.
Separate process from outcome
Review two things separately: Did I follow the plan? (process) and Does the plan work? (outcome). If you did not follow the plan, it is your discipline that needs work – not the strategy.
Try it yourself
Set aside 30 minutes next Sunday. Go through the week’s trades and choose ONE thing you will improve next week.
Key takeaways
- Set aside fixed time for review every week and month.
- Track key numbers such as expectancy in R, drawdown and the share of trades that followed the plan.
- Make one improvement at a time, and test it over many trades.
How much do you remember from “Journal and improvement”?
Recalling what you have read is one of the most effective ways to learn. Pick the answer you think is right – you get the explanation straight away.
1What is the most important field in a trading journal?
A trade that followed the plan is a good trade, whatever the result.
2How many trades do you need to judge a strategy?
With few trades, chance dominates the result.
3You want to improve your trading. What is the best approach?
One change at a time lets you see what actually works.
65% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs with this provider.