3.4 CFDs vs shares, funds and futures
CFDs are one of several tools. They suit some things well and others badly.
Comparison
| CFD | Shares and funds | Futures | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Capital | Margin (leveraged) | The full amount | Margin (leveraged) |
| Short | Easy | Difficult | Easy |
| Size | Flexible, down to small positions | Flexible | Large, standardised contracts |
| Costs | Spread, financing | Commission, fund fees | Commission, no financing |
| Expiry | None (most) | None | Fixed expiry date |
| Suitable horizon | Days and weeks | Years | Days to months |
When do CFDs fit?
- You want to trade short-term moves, up or down.
- You want to trade markets that are hard to reach otherwise, such as currencies, indices and commodities.
- You want to hedge an existing portfolio against a fall.
- You want to trade small positions with precise control of risk.
When do they fit badly?
- Long-term saving. The financing cost eats into the return over time. For saving, low-cost index funds – ideally in a tax-advantaged account where you live – are usually better and cheaper.
- If you do not have time to keep an eye on your positions.
- If you cannot tolerate losses. Leverage means losses can come quickly.
In plain words
CFDs are like renting a car, while shares and funds are like owning one. For a short trip, a rental is practical. If you will use the car for many years, it is cheaper to own it.
Honestly
Most retail traders who trade CFDs lose money. That is rarely because of the product itself, but because of too much leverage, no plan and too little knowledge. The rest of this course is about avoiding exactly that.
Try it yourself
Compare what it costs to hold a share for a year directly and as a leveraged CFD. Include the overnight financing cost.
Key takeaways
- CFDs suit short-term trading, going short and access to many markets.
- For long-term saving, funds and shares are better.
- Most people lose on CFDs because of too much leverage and no plan.
How much do you remember from “When and who trades?”?
Recalling what you have read is one of the most effective ways to learn. Pick the answer you think is right – you get the explanation straight away.
1When is the currency market usually most active (CET)?
When London and New York are open at the same time, there is most trading and the lowest spread.
2Who accounts for most of the trading in the currency market?
Individuals are a small part of the market. The big players move prices.
3You want to save for retirement over 20 years. What fits best?
CFDs have a financing cost every night and suit short-term trading best.
65% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs with this provider.